No, no, no…a thousand times NO: Mars will not become a “second Moon” in the sky on August 27. It won’t this year, it didn’t last year, and it didn’t in the past dozen years since this silly yet strangely perennial cyber-legend (yes I just used the prefix “cyber”) first started circulating on teh interwebz. I don’t know why it keeps rising from the e-dead every year, some years more omnipresently than others, but the bottom line is it simply won’t happen. Not this time, not ever… the Solar System just doesn’t work that way. (And good thing too!)
“But wait,” you say, “couldn’t it happen? Maybe? One day? A what-if scenario?” Again, no. Mars is happily orbiting the Sun, just like Earth and all of the other stuff in the Solar System is according to Newton and Kepler’s lovely laws of gravitation and planetary motion, and it’s not going to come suddenly drifting our way for a visit just for fun. And I’m no physicist but I’d guess that any sort of hypothetical collision event powerful enough to rock a planet from its orbit would more likely shatter Mars apart entirely into a mess of molten rubble, sending chunks our way to create a global meteor shower and forming a temporary new ring of asteroids around the Sun. (But calm down – that’s not going to happen either.)
Not only will Mars not be anywhere near Earth or the Moon as of August 27, it will actually be quite far off: 2.523 AU, or about 234.5 million miles away, and almost on the opposite side of the Sun — it won’t be visible in the night sky at all. Besides, the closest Mars ever gets to Earth is about 35 million miles, which is still much, much too far away for a planet half the size of Earth to appear as large as the Moon (which is about 1/4 the size of our planet) in the sky.
In fact during an opposition event (when Earth and Mars reach their closest points in their respective orbits, which occurs every 2.13 years) on August 27, 2003, Mars came the closest to us in over 50,000 years – and still it was 34.8 million miles away. It was a nice viewing event for amateur astronomers, sure, but still very tiny in the sky compared to the Moon.
That was also when these “double Moon” rumors appear to have started, so perhaps we can just blame bad science reporting for the whole mess.
But the real problem here isn’t necessarily the (very) wrong information, it’s that people otherwise unfamiliar with astronomy who may think this is a special event that they’ll be able to witness for themselves in the night sky end up getting disappointed… which is the opposite of what astronomy should instill in folks.
Said Phil Plait on bis Bad Astronomy blog on Slate.com in 2013:
“We have enough woe and misfortune in the world as it is. Astronomy, the beauty of the sky, and the natural awe laid out before us are instead a source of wonder and joy. I’d prefer to keep them that way.”
So tell your friends, tell your mom, tell your crazy uncle who swears the “S” in NASA stands for “secret alien bases”… two Moons: it’s not gonna happen. But that shouldn’t prevent them from enjoying the beauty of a summer’s evening sky and the one beautiful Moon we do have (it will be nearly full this August 27, too.)
Want to read more? Check out some of the articles below (by some very good science reporters!)
The Cyber-Myth That Just Won’t Die by David Dickinson
No Double Moon in 2015, or Ever by Deborah Byrd
No, Mars Won’t Be As Big As The Moon. Ever. by Phil Plait
Great, just great. So which one of us is going to tell Marvin that his plan to pull Earth into Mars’ orbit has just been cancelled by a little thing like science? I know – let’s send the duck to do it!
On a more serious note, I share your sentiment that rumors like this can lead to disappointment in some cases – and mass pandemonium in others (but that’s more radio than Internet). That people fall prey to rumors like this also points at a lack of real education taking place with regards to some very basic astronomy – or, at the very least, how to properly fact-check Internet rumors.
LikeLiked by 2 people
We try to avoid disappointment in many cases and mass pandemonium whenever possible.
That’s why I think it’s great when astronomy enthusiasts make science available (and understandable) for the public, such as what you do with your blog. When I criticize the lack of education, it’s not a criticism of the scholars or educators; but rather one of those who decide a conversant knowledge of how our solar system works isn’t a high budget priority in their various school systems. In the face of those kinds of decisions, blogs such as yours are standing in the front lines against the disappointments and pandemoniums 🙂
LikeLiked by 2 people
Thanks. I try to keep fighting the good fight!
LikeLiked by 1 person
The thing that’s so alarming about ignorance (besides that it can be so easily cured) is that it makes people credulous and easily fooled. It’s all the more tragic, as stormwise mentions, considering we have this wonderful fount of information at our fingertips.
If you Go Ogle for [Ron Miller planet art] you’ll find some great (and I hasten to point out: not real) images of what it would look like if Jupiter or Saturn or Neptune (et al.) were in the moon’s orbit. Very cool images.
And the Russian Space Agency created a nice YouTube video showing what various other interesting astronomical objects would look like were they much closer.
Who said it could?
Comments are closed.